CORRINA LYNCH · CPC PREPARATION · ADDITIONAL ASSIGNMENT
Chapter A: Reimbursement and the Medical Coder’s Role
By Corrina Lynch
Accurate codes explain what the provider did and why. Payment also depends on coverage, benefits and payer rules.
Learning objectives
- Explain copays, deductibles, coinsurance and allowed amounts.
- Calculate basic insurer payments and patient responsibility.
- Recognize when documentation needs clarification.
The words you need first
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Claim | A request for payment for health care services. |
| Payer | The organization that processes and pays covered claims. |
| Premium | The amount paid to maintain insurance coverage. |
| Allowed amount | The amount the plan recognizes for a covered service. |
| Deductible | The amount the patient pays for services subject to the deductible before the plan begins sharing those costs. |
| Copay | A fixed patient payment. |
| Coinsurance | The patient’s percentage of the allowed amount. |
These are fictional teaching examples. Actual responsibility depends on the plan’s benefits and rules.
Scenario 1: “Why do I owe $25?”
Maria visits an in-network physician for a sore throat. The charge is $150, but the allowed amount is $100. Her benefit requires a $25 copay. No deductible or coinsurance applies to this example.
Discuss: Does Maria owe the $150 charge?
Worked explanation
| Part of the bill | Amount |
|---|---|
| Provider charge | $150 |
| Contractual adjustment | $50 |
| Maria’s copay | $25 |
| Insurance payment | $75 |
The $100 allowed amount is divided between Maria and the insurer. Under this example’s in-network contract, Maria is not billed the $50 adjustment.
Coder connection: Code the documented condition and service. Do not choose codes to match what the patient paid.
Scenario 2: “I have insurance—why is my bill $280?”
James receives a covered, in-network diagnostic service. The allowed amount is $600. He has $200 remaining on his deductible. After the deductible, his plan pays 80% and James pays 20%. No other benefit limits or cost-sharing rules apply to this example.
Discuss: How much does James owe?
Worked explanation
- Apply $200 to the remaining deductible.
- $600 − $200 = $400 remaining.
- James’s coinsurance: 20% × $400 = $80.
- James pays $200 + $80 = $280.
- The insurer pays 80% × $400 = $320.
Check: $280 + $320 = $600.
Coder connection: Codes reflect the record. They do not change because a deductible is unmet.
Scenario 3: “The claim was denied—should I change the diagnosis?”
An outpatient diagnostic-test claim is denied because the submitted documentation does not support medical necessity. The coder finds an order, but the reason for the test is unclear.
Discuss: Should the coder add a diagnosis to make the claim payable?
Worked explanation
No. Review the record and denial reason. If clarification is needed, follow the organization’s provider-query process. Report only supported information. The findings may support additional documentation, a corrected claim or an appeal.
Coder connection: A denial is a reason to investigate—not permission to invent a diagnosis.
Scenario 4: “Why was there another charge during my wellness visit?”
During a Medicare annual wellness visit, Denise reports a new problem. The physician performs and documents a significant, separately identifiable, medically necessary evaluation of that problem.
Discuss: Is this additional evaluation automatically included in the wellness visit?
Worked explanation
A separate problem-oriented E/M service may be reportable when supported. CMS directs providers to append modifier 25 to the additional E/M code in this situation. Payment and patient responsibility depend on applicable rules. An annual wellness visit is not the same service as a routine physical.
Coder connection: Mentioning another condition alone does not establish a separate billable service. Review the documented work.
CPC study focus: ABNs and RBRVS
ABN — Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage
The ABN (Form CMS-R-131) is used for Original Medicare when payment for a normally covered item or service is expected to be denied in a particular situation. When required to transfer potential liability, give the notice before the service, explain the specific reason Medicare may not pay and provide an estimated cost. It does not guarantee payment and is not a blanket notice for every patient. A voluntary notice may be used for services Medicare never covers.
Mini-scenario: A nonurgent test may exceed a Medicare coverage frequency limit. Review the applicable coverage policy and whether an ABN is required before the test. Do not wait for a denial to obtain it.
RBRVS — Resource-Based Relative Value Scale
Medicare physician fee schedule payment uses three relative value unit components: physician work, practice expense and malpractice expense. Each component has its own geographic practice cost index (GPCI). The adjusted total is multiplied by the applicable conversion factor.
Basic formula: [(work RVU × work GPCI) + (practice-expense RVU × practice-expense GPCI) + (malpractice RVU × malpractice GPCI)] × conversion factor.
Mini-scenario: If fictional geographically adjusted RVUs total 3 and the example conversion factor is $30, the base payment calculation is 3 × $30 = $90. These are teaching numbers, not actual Medicare rates; other payment adjustments may apply.
Remember the three RVU components and what GPCI and conversion factor do. Do not assume every service is paid under the same payment system.
RVU components: your illustrated example
| Component | What it represents | Example adjusted RVUs |
|---|---|---|
| Work RVU | Clinician time, skill, effort and judgment | 1.50 |
| Practice expense RVU | Office staff, supplies, equipment and overhead | 1.10 |
| Malpractice RVU | Professional liability expense | 0.20 |
1.50 + 1.10 + 0.20 = 2.80 adjusted RVUs. These example components are already geographically adjusted. Do not apply GPCI a second time.
If the fictional conversion factor is $35: 2.80 × $35 = $98 before other applicable payment adjustments. The $35 factor is a teaching number, not an actual current Medicare rate.
Other concepts to review
- Medical necessity and documentation supporting the codes reported.
- National versus local coverage policies (NCDs and LCDs).
- Bundling and NCCI edits: a modifier must be supported, not simply added to bypass an edit.
- Correct coding versus guaranteed coverage: an accurate code does not guarantee payment.
These study topics supplement the 10-question scenario assignment; they are not additional scored questions.
CMS ABN guidance · CMS physician fee schedule calculation
Insurance, claims and compliance: beginner reference
Medicare Parts A, B, C and D
| Part | Main coverage | Teaching example |
|---|---|---|
| A — Hospital insurance | Inpatient hospital care, qualifying skilled nursing facility care, hospice and some home health care | An inpatient hospital facility stay. Physician services during the stay are generally billed under Part B. |
| B — Medical insurance | Physician services, outpatient care, durable medical equipment and many preventive services | An office visit or physician service. |
| C — Medicare Advantage | A Medicare-approved private-plan alternative providing Part A and Part B benefits, usually with Part D; applicable exceptions remain | Verify the plan’s network, authorization and billing requirements. |
| D — Drug coverage | Prescription drug coverage through Medicare-approved plans | A covered prescription filled at a pharmacy. Some drugs are covered under Part B instead. |
Remember: Original Medicare is Parts A and B. Medigap supplements Original Medicare cost sharing; it is not Medicare Advantage. Medicaid is a separate joint federal/state program with eligibility and coverage rules that vary by state.
Commercial insurance and networks
| Term | Plain-language meaning |
|---|---|
| Commercial insurance | Private insurance, often employer-sponsored or individually purchased. |
| HMO | Usually restricts care to its network except emergencies. Referral requirements depend on the plan. |
| PPO | Usually costs less in-network and allows out-of-network care at greater cost without a specialist referral. |
| Referral | A provider’s direction to obtain another service or specialist care; plan rules determine when it is required. |
| Prior authorization | Payer approval required before certain services. Approval is not a guarantee of payment. |
Who pays first?
Coordination of benefits determines the primary and secondary payer when there is more than one plan. Medicare is not always primary. Employment, type of coverage and other circumstances matter. Secondary coverage does not automatically pay everything left over.
Mini-scenario: A patient has Medicare plus employer coverage. Verify the applicable coordination rules before deciding which payer receives the first claim.
How a claim moves through payment
| Item | What students should know |
|---|---|
| CMS-1500 / 837P | Professional paper claim / electronic professional claim. |
| CMS-1450 (UB-04) / 837I | Institutional paper claim / electronic institutional claim. |
| EOB | Explanation of benefits sent to the member; it explains processing and is not itself a bill. |
| Remittance advice / ERA | Payment and adjustment information sent to the provider. CARCs and RARCs help explain adjustments. |
| Rejected or unprocessable claim | Generally cannot proceed through normal adjudication because required information or format is invalid. Correct and resubmit according to payer instructions. |
| Denied claim | Processed with a nonpayment decision. Review the stated reason to determine whether correction, documentation or appeal is appropriate. |
Mini-scenario: An invalid member identifier produces a rejection; correct the identifier. A medical-necessity denial requires review of coverage and documented clinical support. Neither situation permits inventing a diagnosis.
Payment and compliance reminders
- Accepting Medicare assignment: Accept the Medicare-approved amount as full payment for the covered service, with applicable patient deductible and coinsurance.
- Participating provider: Agrees to accept assignment for covered Medicare services. A nonparticipating provider may accept assignment case by case. Nonparticipating is different from opting out.
- Global surgical package: Certain preoperative, operative and related postoperative services are included in one payment. Review the procedure’s global period and rules before reporting related follow-up care separately.
- Upcoding: Reporting a higher level or more extensive service than the documentation supports.
- Unbundling: Separately reporting components that should be included together under applicable coding rules.
- Fraud versus abuse: Fraud involves intentional deception or misrepresentation; abuse includes improper practices that can cause unnecessary costs or improper payment without establishing that same intent. Investigate and correct errors rather than automatically labeling every mistake fraud.
Coder rule: Report supported care, check payer requirements and escalate unclear documentation through the proper process.
Official references for this section
- Medicare: Parts and coverage options
- HealthCare.gov: HMO and PPO networks
- Medicare: Coordination of benefits
- CMS: Professional claims
- CMS: Institutional claims
- CMS: Remittance advice
- Medicare: Assignment and provider status
- CMS: Global surgery
- HHS OIG: Compliance education
This reference section adds reading material. Thursday’s scored class assignment remains 10 questions.
Scenario 5: Hospital outpatient colonoscopy — APC
A patient has a colonoscopy in a hospital outpatient department and goes home the same day.
Ask first: Who is being paid, and is the patient inpatient or outpatient?
Worked explanation
This scenario concerns the hospital’s outpatient facility services. Under Medicare’s OPPS, applicable CPT/HCPCS services are assigned to Ambulatory Payment Classification (APC) groups. Some related services are packaged into another payment. The physician’s professional service is separate and generally follows the physician fee schedule.
Remember: APC = Ambulatory Payment Classification, a hospital outpatient payment grouping. APC is not the name of a procedure code. Report required facility services even when payment is packaged, according to applicable reporting rules.
Scenario 6: Physician service — RBRVS
A physician provides an outpatient office or procedural service.
Ask first: Are we discussing physician payment or hospital facility payment?
Worked explanation
The physician service has work, practice expense and malpractice RVUs. Geographic adjustments and the applicable conversion factor help determine the payment basis.
Teaching math: 1.50 + 1.10 + 0.20 = 2.80 adjusted RVUs. With a hypothetical $35 conversion factor, 2.80 × $35 = $98, before other applicable adjustments. These are fictional teaching numbers.
Remember: RBRVS values the resources for the physician service; the physician fee schedule uses that value to calculate payment. Facility and professional payments are different.
Bundling and unbundling: worked examples
Bundling means a component is included in a more comprehensive service under applicable rules. Improper unbundling means reporting an included component separately to obtain additional payment.
Example 1: Same polyp, two techniques
During colonoscopy, the physician takes a biopsy of a polyp and then removes that same polyp by snare.
Discuss: Should the biopsy automatically be reported in addition to the snare removal?
Explanation: The biopsy of that same lesion is included in the removal in this example. Do not add modifier 59 merely to obtain payment for both services. Review the applicable current CPT instructions and NCCI edit.
Example 2: Different polyps, distinct services
The physician biopsies one lesion and removes a different lesion by snare. The record clearly distinguishes the lesions and work performed.
Explanation: Separate reporting may be appropriate when the code instructions and NCCI edit permit it. A supported modifier 59 or more specific applicable modifier may identify the distinct service. Separate lesions do not make every code pair separately reportable; check the edit and payer rules.
Example 3: Routine postoperative follow-up
The surgeon performs routine, related postoperative follow-up during the procedure’s global period.
Explanation: Covered routine postoperative care is included in the surgical package. Separately billing it as a new payable office visit would be improper in this example. Unrelated care or other exceptions require supported documentation and the appropriate coding rules.
Do not confuse: OPPS packaging concerns facility payment. NCCI bundling concerns coding edits. A packaged service may still need reporting on the facility claim even though it has no separate payment.
CMS: OPPS/APC · CMS: Gastroenterology modifier 59 examples · CMS: Global surgery
These added discussion scenarios do not increase the 10-question scored class assignment.
Chapter Review — 10 Questions
Choose one answer per question. Each question is worth 1 point.
- A request for payment for health care services is a:
- A. Premium
- B. Claim
- C. Deductible
- A fixed $25 patient payment is a:
- A. Copay
- B. Coinsurance
- C. Contractual adjustment
- The amount a plan recognizes for a covered service is the:
- A. Provider’s charge
- B. Premium
- C. Allowed amount
- In Scenario 1, how much does Maria owe?
- A. $150
- B. $25
- C. $100
- In Scenario 2, how much deductible remains before the service?
- A. $200
- B. $400
- C. $600
- What is 20% of the remaining $400?
- A. $20
- B. $80
- C. $200
- What is James’s total responsibility?
- A. $80
- B. $200
- C. $280
- When documentation is unclear, the coder should:
- A. Invent a payable diagnosis
- B. Seek appropriate clarification
- C. Ignore the record
- Which modifier may identify a qualifying separate E/M service during the wellness visit?
- A. 25
- B. 50
- C. 59
- Code selection should reflect:
- A. The desired payment
- B. The patient’s deductible
- C. The documented care
References
- HealthCare.gov: Health coverage glossary
- CMS: E/M documentation and medical necessity
- CMS: Annual wellness visit and separate E/M services
CPC preparation material authored by Corrina Lynch. This is not an official AAPC publication.